Showing posts with label A Bridge too Far. Show all posts
Showing posts with label A Bridge too Far. Show all posts

13 May 2024

Deventer, Netherlands


   
For the film A BRIDGE TOO FAR producer Joseph E. Levine aimed to film as much as possible on location in the Netherlands, where events had taken place during Operation Market Garden in World War II. However, not a single scene would be filmed in Arnhem, the Gelderland capital where the bridge from the title stands.

A Bridge Too Far, 2:41:28
The film is based on the book of the same name by Cornelius Ryan from 1974, about the Allied military offensive against Nazi Germany in September 1944, both from the air (Market) and on the ground (Garden). British, Polish and American troops managed to capture key bridges in the south of the Netherlands, including the Waal Bridge (see also Nijmegen, Netherlands).

The advance stalled at the Rhine Bridge in Arnhem. Operation Market Garden failed, although the south of the Netherlands was liberated.

Deventer seen from the Wilhelmina Bridge, 30 April 2024 
Filming started on 26 April 1976. In the more than 30 years that had passed since the Battle of Arnhem, the area around the Rhine Bridge had changed much due to postwar architecture that a the World War II movie could not be filmed here. Yugoslavia was briefly considered, until Deventer came into the picture: also an arch bridge and an area where little had changed since the war.

To mark the film's 45th anniversary, local broadcaster RTV Oost published a report on 26 April 2021, Hollywood in Deventer: 45 years ago, the city was the setting for a world-famous war film, on filming in Deventer. The presence of the film crew reportedly earned the city 5 million guilders (2.3 million euros/2.4 million US dollars).

Deventer is first seen when German soldiers walk through Arnhem. They are watched by the son (Erik van 't Wout) of a resistance leader (Siem Vroom) from his room. The soldiers walk from Kerksteeg to Rijkmanstraat; the resistance leader's house is number 48. This was the first scene filmed.

A Bridge Too Far, 0:10:12
Corner Kerksteeg and Rijkmanstraat, Deventer, 30 April 2024 
A Bridge Too Far, 0:10:19
Rijkmanstraat 48, Deventer, 30 April 2024

Operation Market Garden has begun. In Leopoldsburg, Flanders, Lieutenant General Brian Horrocks (Edward Fox) arrives at the headquarters of the XXX Corps. Brink, the central square in Deventer city centre, was chosen to represent the Belgian city. The building in the background is De Waag, built from 1528 to 1531 and now Museum De Waag.

A Bridge Too Far, 0:28:13
De Waag, Brink, Deventer, 30 April 2024

At cinema Splendid, Horrocks gives a briefing on the operation. Splendid had been demolished in 1973, this is cinema Luxor Plaza at Brink 20. In 1977, A Bridge Too Far was shown at Luxor Plaza, which must have been a strange sensation for the visitors: on the screen, you see the room you are in. The cinema closed in 1983 but the building remained, now home to event venue Chicago Club.

A Bridge Too Far, 0:28:52
Chicago Club, Brink 20, Deventer, 30 April 2024

The 2nd Parachute Battalion, led by Lieutenant Colonel John Frost (Anthony Hopkins), has reached Arnhem after landing on the Ginkelse Heide. The soldiers walk from Duimpoort to Polstraat in the old centre of Deventer. The Wilhelmina Bridge can be seen for the first time, as well as the tower of the Lebuinus Church. The bridge, named after the then queen of the Netherlands, was blown up by the Germans in 1945 and rebuilt in 1948 according to the original design.

A Bridge Too Far, 1:13:02
Duimpoort, Deventer, 30 April 2024
A Bridge Too Far, 1:13:16
Polstraat, Deventer, 30 April 2024

Next to the Wilhelmina Bridge was a car park in 1976. A set consisting of several houses was built here. Today it is a car park.

A Bridge Too Far, 1:13:36
Emmastraat, Deventer, 30 April 2024

Frost and Major Harry Carlyle (Christopher Good) go up on the roof of one of these houses to view the bridge. The Bergkerk or St Nicholas Church can be seen in the background. The Rhine Bridge in Arnhem would be named after John Frost (1912-1993) in 1978.

A Bridge Too Far, 1:15:30
Bergkerk, Deventer, 30 April 2024

Carlyle walks onto the bridge with an umbrella. Holding up the umbrella would be the signal to advance. In reality, this was done by this Major Digby Tatham-Warter. To the left of the bridge, across the river IJssel, the sails of the Bolwerks Mill can be seen.

A Bridge Too Far, 1:15:43
Wilhelmina Bridge, Deventer, 30 April 2024
A Bridge Too Far, 1:15:56
Wilhelmina Bridge, Deventer, 30 April 2024

Wilhelmina Fountain,
Deventer, 30 April 2024
After Eindhoven is liberated, residents celebrate exuberantly in the streets. The tank of Lieutenant Colonel John O.E. Vandeleur (Michael Caine) drives across Brink, now filmed from the other side. In the centre of the square is the Wilhelmina Fountain, just like the bridge named after the queen. The statue standing on the column represents the Deventer city maiden. The fountain dates from 1898, the year of Wilhelmina's inauguration. Between 1960 and 1985, and thus also during filming, the fountain had been removed because of car traffic. Since 1993, the square has been car-free.

A Bridge Too Far, 1:31:00
Brink, Deventer, 30 April 2024

After German sergeant Matthias (Lex van Delden) has crossed the bridge with the white flag, he returns to General Wilhelm Bittrich (Maximilian Schell) to give a report. The bridge can now be seen from Bolwerksweg.

A Bridge Too Far, 2:00:55
Bolwerksweg, Deventer, 30 April 2024

In Arnhem, the resistance leader sees in horror that there are many deaths to mourn. Kerksteeg 12, opposite the previously mentioned Bergkerk.

A Bridge Too Far, 2:01:54
Kerksteeg 12, Deventer, 30 April 2024

Jan Spaander (Laurence Olivier), a Dutch doctor, is taken by the Germans and is driven through a destroyed Arnhem. Muggeplein in the Noordenberg Quarter, which was a neighbourhood in decline mid-70s but has since been completely renewed. The only similarity between 1976 and 2024 is the spire of the Lebuinus Church, circled in red.

A Bridge Too Far, 2:37:32
Muggeplein, Deventer, 30 April 2024

Deventer is last seen as Major General Stanisław Sosabowski (Gene Hackman), Lieutenant General Frederick Browning (Dirk Bogarde), Brigadier General James Gavin (Ryan O'Neal), Horrocks and Vandeleur meet atop a church tower. Again the Lebuinis Church, at 38 Grote Kerkhof. The actors were not actually standing on the church tower, this was a set built on the other side of the Wilhelmina Bridge. However, it is possible to climb the 220 steps of the 46-metre (150 feet) church tower, for more information see the Lebuinis Church website.

A Bridge Too Far, 2:40:29
Lebuinis Church, Deventer, 30 April 2024
A Bridge Too Far, 2:40:39
Lebuinis Church, Deventer, 30 April 2024

Many thanks to the website Strijdbewijs (Dutch only) for background information.

For an overview of every location in this movie, see my blog Hollands Decor (in Dutch).

Screenshots © Joseph E. Levine Productions
 

27 July 2015

Nijmegen, Netherlands


   
For A BRIDGE TOO FAR, the film by director Richard Attenborough based on the book with the same name by Cornelius Ryan about Operation Market Garden, cost nor effort were spared. With a budget of 26 million dollar it was the most expensive movie made up to then. Between April and October of 1976 on location shoots with an all-star cast were made on several places in the Netherlands. The local stores of Deventer, where the major part was filmed, did good business.

A Bridge too Far, 1:55:35
Recently I found out that also Nijmegen, the city I have been living since 1987, is seen in the movie as well.
Unlike the Arnhem bridge, the Waal Bridge was successfully secured by the allied forces but at the cost of many lives. On 20 September 1944 the bridge was recaptured from the Germans by attacking it from two sides.

An extended report on the battle of the Waal Bridge can be found on the website Strijdbewijs (Dutch only). The differences between what really happened and the movie are also explained which I used, with gratitude, for this blog.
The Waal Bridge was formally opened on 16 June 1936 by Queen Wilhelmina, as is shown in the cinema journal Polygoon. The bridge connects Nijmegen with Lent and the northern parts of the Netherlands. During World War II it was one of the most important bridges in the Netherlands to be recaptured from the Germans, along with the nearby railroad bridge.

The days of shooting in Nijmegen were the last of the movie. Because of the sunny and warm summer of 1976 filming had proceeded as scheduled but at the end of September the weather was more cloudy. The city of Nijmegen had agreed in closing the bridge for all traffic, including boats, on three Sunday mornings but no longer than one hour for each day. Three hours were sufficient and on 3 October 1976 the final scenes were filmed.

A Bridge too Far, 1:55:50
Waal Bridge, Nijmegen, 10 May 2015

The Waal Bridge is first seen when General-major Karl Ludwig (Hardy Krüger), in Nijmegen, watches his army march over the bridge. In reality his name was Harmel and he was watching from Lent on the other side of the river. Behind the general is the St. Stevens Church. The tower however had collapsed during the bombing of Nijmegen on 22 February 1944. The third time the tower is shown the image is mirrored. The church was rebuilt after the war and restored in 2015, which explains the scaffolds seen by the small tower.

A Bridge too Far, 1:55:38
St. Stevens Church, Nijmegen, 15 May 2015
A Bridge too Far, 1:55:46
Waal Bridge, Nijmegen, 10 May 2015
A Bridge too Far, 2:12:40
St. Stevens Church, Nijmegen, 15 May 2015
A Bridge too Far, 2:16:02
St. Stevens Church, Nijmegen, 15 May 2015

In the film the explosives that are attached under the bridge are clearly visible, in reality these were hidden. The Germans wanted to destroy the bridge if the allied forces would recapture it. In the meantime German soldiers, played by Dutch extras, are climbing on top of the bridge and tying themselves so they cannot fall off.

A Bridge too Far, 2:16:03
Waal Bridge, Nijmegen, 15 May 2015
A Bridge too Far, 2:16:07
Waal Bridge, Nijmegen, 15 May 2015
A Bridge too Far, 2:16:10
Waal Bridge, Nijmegen, 15 May 2015

Blowing up the bridge was not going to happen: a part did not go off, another part was deactivated by the Americans and already on 18 September Jan van Hoof, member of the resistance, had cut several fuses.
He was killed the following day during fights at the Waalkade, near the bridge. After the war a memorial stone was placed on one of the pillars of the bridge, made by Jac. Maris and revealed on 18 September 1945.
Jan van Hoof is depicted while defusing the bombs. The text under the sculpture reads "Aan Jan v. Hoof, zijn medestrijders, 18-IX-1945 O.Str.Nymegen" (To Jan van Hoof, his fellow combatants, 18-IX-1945 O.Str.Nijmegen).

The place where he died, the corner of the Lange Hezelstraat and the Nieuwe Markt, was marked in 1945 by a commerative plate in the pavement. It reads, in Dutch, "Jan van Hoof fell here, Saviour of the Waal Bridge, 19_9_1944". The stone plate is now part of Joris Ivens Square, which is within walking distance from the Waalkade. Jan van Hoof's name is also on the Resistance Monument at the Trajanus Square.

Commanded by Major Julian Cook (Robert Redford), the 82nd Airborne Division is crossing the Waal in canvas assault boats. They are immediately attacked with heavy fire by the Germans. The river was crossed on the west side of the railroad bridge. Because of the urban surroundings that were built after the war, these scenes were filmed on the east of the Waal Bridge, now rowing from north to south. In the background the chimney of De Vlietberg, a stone factory in the Ooy Polder, can be seen. Protests of owners of nearby houseboats were rejected by the council of Ubbergen because there was no law prohibiting “three days of explosions”.

A Bridge too Far, 2:12:43
Waal River, 15 May 2015

After reaching the other side of the river fights between the Americans and the Germans continue. Major Cook and his men manage to reach the bridge quickly and again they are met with heavy fire, amongst others at the viaduct which now bears the name of Sergeant Peter Robinson. It was named after Sergeant Robinson of the British Grenadier Guards who was the first to cross the Waal Bridge with his tank on 20 September 1944.

A Bridge too Far, 2:16:16
Waal Bridge seen from Lent, 15 May 2015
A Bridge too Far, 2:16:23
Sergeant Robinsonviaduct, Lent, 15 May 2015 
Sergeant Robinsonviaduct, Lent, 15 May 2015 

After the Waal River broke its banks in 1993 and 1995 threatening Nijmegen with floods, it was decided to, amongst others, construct an ancillary channel and an extension of the bridge in Lent. Work started in 2012, at the time the photos were made it was still in progress. The project will be finalized in 2016.

A Bridge too Far, 2:16:19
Waal Bridge, Lent, 15 May 2015
A Bridge too Far, 2:18:10
Waal Bridge, Lent, 15 May 2015

The Waal Bridge itself has also changed. Besides being repainted the bridge has been broaded in the 90’s on the west side for a bus lane. The stone pillar that Major Cook hides behind was removed and replaced with an iron fence. On the other side of the bridge the pillars remain, to compare the situations then and now a photo of the east side is included as well, even though the scene was filmed on the west side.

A Bridge too Far, 2:17:40
Waal Bridge, Nijmegen, 15 May 2015
A Bridge too Far, 2:17:42
Waal Bridge, Nijmegen, 10 May 2015
A Bridge too Far, 2:17:49
Waal Bridge, Nijmegen, 15 May 2015
A Bridge too Far, 2:17:53
Waal Bridge, Nijmegen, 15 May 2015

Memorial for the Grenadier Guards
placed on the Waal Bridge in 1994
During filming it became clear that the part that the Grenadier Guards commanded by the above mentioned Sergeant Robinson had in capturing the bridge was left out which made it seem as if the Americans did it all on their own, which is historically incorrect. The taking of the railroad bridge was also left out of the screenplay. After several protests this distorted image of the actual situation was partly changed by filming an additional scene. Tanks of the Grenadier Guards are seen driving from the Waalkade towards the Waal Bridge.

Most houses at the Oude Haven have been demolished in the 80’s to make room for new buildings. Still recognizable is the house at number 102 (built in 1906, until recently a galerie) and the large patrician’s house dating from around 1780 with numbers 104 until 108a. The building is called De Zeemeermin (The Mermaid), because of the decoration surrounding the window above the entrance. In 1983 the house was completely restored to its original state.

A Bridge too Far, 2:17:14
Oude Haven, Nijmegen, 10 May 2015
A Bridge too Far, 2:17:17
Oude Haven, Nijmegen, 10 May 2015
De Zeemeermin, Oude Haven, Nijmegen, 10 May 2015
A Bridge too Far, 2:17:35
Waal Bridge, Nijmegen, 15 May 2015
A Bridge too Far, 2:18:26
Waal Bridge, Nijmegen, 15 May 2015

Since Robert Redford was one of the film’s main stars he is seen in the final scene, while tanks cross the Waal Bridge. Princess Margriet of the Netherlands and her husband LLM Pieter van Vollenhoven paid a visit to the set in Nijmegen.

A Bridge too Far, 2:19:45
Waal Bridge, Nijmegen, 15 May 2015
A Bridge too Far, 2:19:48
Waal Bridge, Nijmegen, 15 May 2015
LLM Pieter van Vollenhoven, Robert Redford,
and Princess Margriet
Amigoe di Curaçao, 7 October 1976

During the crossing 48 soldiers were killed. I’m glad Nijmegen has not forgotten them. When a third bridge was completed in 2013 it was called The Crossing, commemorating this heroic event. It has 48 pairs of lanterns that are lit every evening one by one while a veteran crosses the bridge. The names of all 48 men are also on a memorial at the Oosterhoutse Dijk.

Waal Crossing Memorial, Oosterhoutse Dijk,
Nijmegen, 22 March 2021

For an overview of every location in this movie, see my blog Hollands Decor (in Dutch).

Screenshots © Joseph E. Levine Productions
News paper photo © Amigoe di Curaçao